Shop file · 17 first-hand accounts · updated September 2026
PreOwnedWeddingDresses: What Brides Paid
10 prices reported at PreOwnedWeddingDresses run a median $575, from $200 to $1,100. That sits below the $850 median across every route in this dataset. Separately, 17 brides described what the shop was like to deal with, and 94% of them recommend it.
What brides paid
Every row is one bride: what she paid for the gown, what the tailoring came to when she reported it, and the year.
| Gown | Tailoring | Year | The account |
|---|---|---|---|
| $200 | – | 2022 | New with tags; whole look including alterations and accessories expected well under 1000 |
| $300 | – | 2016 | Gown over 1000 retail, never worn with tags still on, sold by a bride who changed her mind. |
| $350 | – | 2026 | Sample of a 3000 gown bought online for 350; alterations and extras brought the real cost to about 1000. Still felt worth it. |
| $400 | – | 2022 | Blush gown with 9500 retail bought for 400; second dress 200 (retail 4200) had a tiny makeup stain inside the bodice |
| $450 | – | 2019 | Dream gown found used after a 1000 budget failed; the same style retailed at 1300 |
| $700 | – | 2017 | Bought a sample gown listed on the resale site. |
| $800 | – | 2022 | New with tags, about 500 under retail; seller's covid date change; buyer had regretted two earlier dresses |
| $900 | – | 2019 | Gown retailed at 2500; nothing comparable in local boutiques so she gambled on resale |
| $1,000 | $750 | 2023 | Discontinued dream gown that had retailed around 10000-12000 found used for 1000; alterations added about 750 and the result was exactly right |
| $1,100 | $950 | 2022 | NWT Maggie Sottero Trystin from an Indiana shop; alterations cover hem, corset conversion and many bustle buttons |
What brides recommend it for
- A Mori Lee gown over 1000 retail, never worn with tags on, for 300 from a bride who changed her mind. She rates the whole buying experience.
- Discontinued gown that had retailed around 10000-12000 bought for 1000, plus roughly 750 in alterations; called the result perfect
- Found a Maggie Sottero 'Charlene' there; a bridal 4 fit her street size 0-2 frame well and total alterations came to 64 dollars
- Used it as a seller after her wedding: cleaned the gown professionally, listed it and recovered about a third of what she paid
- Tried on a Maggie Sottero Boston listed there while dress hunting and says the skirt and train matched exactly this brief
- Found the style she loved for 450 after browsing the site; the same gown retailed at 1300 and she reports no dress regret
- Searched it on a whim for the Lillian West gown she loved in a shop and found one unworn and preowned inside her budget.
- Sold a dress there rather quickly; there is a listing fee, and she warns you will not recover the full amount.
- Also fell for a gown above budget and got it within budget by buying used; says the experience went very well
- Bought her dress there and had a good experience; also points to the site's accessories section for veils
What brides warn about
- Same experience as StillWhite: real bargains exist but the listings are padded with overpriced worn dresses.
How it compares
The median across every route in this dataset is $850, a bridal salon runs $1,900, and secondhand sits lower again. A shop is worth judging against the route it belongs to rather than against the whole market, which is what the where-to-buy page sets out.
Sources
Price reports on this page come from 7 public discussions where brides answered in their own words. Each comment that stated an amount became one row; notes are paraphrased, never quoted.
Discussions used on this page (7)
- 2022-03: How much have you spent or are you planning to spend on your wedding dress? (397 comments)
- 2022-01: Is $500 an unreasonably cheap budget for a wedding dress? (270 comments)
- 2026-02: Buyers remorse wedding dress $1800 (182 comments)
- 2019-10: I found a dress I’m absolutely in love with, but it’s a little bit over my budget and I’m struggling to justify that much amount of money for a dress I’ll be wearing less than 24 hours. Has anyone else struggled with that feeling and what did you end up doing? (115 comments)
- 2023-10: Bridal shop put me in a dress $1,100 over budget without me knowing. How do I let go of it and move on? (107 comments)
- 2017-05: Any other places like BHLDN that offer beautiful but affordable wedding dresses? (52 comments)
- 2016-12: Show me your under $500 wedding dress! (44 comments)